Elections

Cambridge City Council elections, May 2023: West Chesterton

Summary: Elections to Cambridge City Council in May 2023
Polling date: Thursday 4th May 2023
Ward:
Candidates
(by surname):
  • Jamie Leon DALZELL  (Liberal Democrat)
  • Michael John HARFORD  (Conservative Party)
  • Shayne Mary MITCHELL  (Green Party)
  • Rachel Lynne WADE  (Labour Party)

Questions for West Chesterton ward candidates (5 questions)

Jump to question:  1   2   3   4   5 

# Question 1

What improvements for active travel and public space would you like to see at Mitcham's Corner?

Jamie Leon DALZELL
(Liberal Democrat)

The gyratory was originally built before the A14 and helped heavy duty vehicles travel through Cambridge on their way to ports east of the city. As noted by the Friends of Mitcham’s Corner, times have changed and there is fantastic potential to develop Mitcham’s corner very differently.

I continue to support the proposal to cut the gyratory and implement a low-speed environment which would be vastly improved for cyclists and pedestrians. The ideas are clearly explained in the Mitcham's Corner Development Framework (an SPD in the Local Plan), which I continue to support.

The key element that continues to be missing is the funding. I continue to lobby for the GCP to look at this site as part of future projects that can (hopefully) build on the success of the Milton Road scheme and apply similar standards across the north of Cambridge.

Michael John HARFORD
(Conservative Party)

None for now.

Shayne Mary MITCHELL
(Green Party)

It is rare to see a cyclist daring to venture round Mitcham's Corner. It is currently far too intimidating and dangerous. I have twice been hit from behind when leaving Milton Road to enter Mitcham's Corner, once on a bike, once in a car.

This is what would help:-

20 mph speed limit - or slower.

Block the cut-through from Mitcham's Corner to Chesterton Road, by Lloyds, so that the pavement is continuous and so that pedestrians are not intimidated by trying to cross this unnecessary bit of road, where you cannot tell if a car is going to turn into it as no one signals.

Zebra crossings, not pelican crossings.

Where there are pelican crossings, make the timings friendly to pedestrians, not to vehicles. Don't make us wait for up to a minute in the wind and rain, as dry drivers sail past in their cosy warm cars.

Improve the crossroads of Chesterton Road, Ferry Lane, and Herbert Street, outside the Co-op, so that it is safe for cyclists and pedestrians to cross. It is heavily used by pedestrians and by cyclists who cross Chesterton Road here, but there is no provision for them and no safety.

Narrow the road as you enter Mitcham's Corner from Milton Road, and put a clear STOP sign on the road, so that we are safe cycling onto and round Mitcham's Corner here.

Address the problem of motor vehicles accelerating fast away from Mitcham's Corner, round the corner into Chesterton Road, and along Chesterton Road outside Barclay's.

Remove visually intrusive and ugly advertising clutter - the garishly illuminated boards on the pavement outside Barclay's (which block the pavement), the advertising signs as you enter Mitcham's Corner from Milton Road, which distract motorists and block their view of oncoming cyclists.

Repair the damaged stone wall around the pleasant raised grassy green near Lloyds.

Install a zebra crossing from the island at the bottom of Victoria Road across to the other side, outside the old Staples building.

Slow traffic down as it whizzes round the corner by the Portland Arms, ready to hit cyclists and people crossing Milton Road from right to left just round the (blind) corner, before the zebra crossing. It is a heavily used "path of desire".

Benches. Noticeboards for local events.

Better control of new shop fronts and new buildings so that they fit in with the pleasing existing Victorian/early twentieth century shopfronts.

Encouragement to dawdle, to idle, to pause, rather than the current intimidating Hyde Park Corner effect.

Changes to road surface/colour to make clear that it is somewhere which prioritises people, not motor vehicles.

Rachel Lynne WADE
(Labour Party)

New cycle lane, road markings are a hard fought ,impressive improvement at Mitcham's by West Chesterton residents , Councillors alike. Residents I have spoken to recently seem very encouraged by this move forward. The new" cycle lane/ line" markings are very clear and encourage safe active travel.I would continue to consult widely with the Mitcham's Corner group,County and City Councillors, business owners, residents to engage and empower decisions that can produce such positive outcomes for both safe active travel and sustainable public transport.

# Question 2

With substantial width, Chesterton Road has significant potential for walking and cycling improvements. What changes would you support on this key route to shops, services and many local schools?

Jamie Leon DALZELL
(Liberal Democrat)

I would link this question to the first; I do not see Chesterton Road and Mitcham’s Corner as separate (the former is just unfortunately currently a feature of the latter).

I would like to see the ‘Do Optimum’ principles that are being largely applied on Milton Road to be expanded across all of Chesterton Road, which is becoming a successful, bustling hub for our community (with a large number of the best bike shops, restaurants, cafes, bars and pubs in Cambridge).

Under those principles, I would expect to see segregated cycle lanes and the reinstatement of trees and other planting along Chesterton Road (it was originally built as a tree lined avenue but was widened for heavy vehicles which instead now use the A14).

Several years ago, I brought this topic for discussion at the Camcycle monthly meeting, and we also looked at the opportunity for introducing Copenhagen crossings (which prioritise pedestrians) to most of the wide junctions along the road. There is great opportunity for improvements, and I hope we can harness the skills and knowledge developed on other schemes to get on and deliver this.

Michael John HARFORD
(Conservative Party)

None for now.

Shayne Mary MITCHELL
(Green Party)

It always seems to me that the stretch of Chesterton Road from Mitcham's Corner to the roundabout could easily, with a bit of paint, be transformed. No heavy engineering, just a decent wide legally enforceable cycle lane (current one is much better than before), double yellow lines, enforce no parking on pavements, and especially not on the dual use pedestrian/cyclist pavement on the north side.

See also suggestions in question 1 re Mitcham's Corner.

A proper crossing, and dropped kerbs for pushchairs, etc, across Chesterton Road at the end of Chesterton Hall Crescent.

It looks to me as if this stretch of road between Mitcham's Corner and the roundabout would be wide enough to have a strip of trees along the middle - a boulevard! Surely do-able if there were narrower vehicle lanes, such as in Hills Road.

Junction of Ferry Lane and Chesterton Road - this is currently dangerous for the many cyclists and pedestrians emerging onto Chesterton Road and going to the pelican crossing, as drivers swing fast into Ferry Lane, and often use it to do unexpected U-turns. The pavement could be built out at the corner to prevent this.

Remove the obstructive clutter of large signs, etc outside the Spar shop.

Rachel Lynne WADE
(Labour Party)

I would listen very carefully to ideas from the local community around improvements that they feel empowered to identify,as a pedestrian and bus user myself , I am aware that Cambridge needs to encourage harmonious shared use of pavements and cycle ways for pedestrians and cyclists alike.along with convenient, connected, public transport.Traffic of all types, ebbs and flows at different times of day,making areas safe for all users is paramount.I look forward to engaging with the local community to hear their suggestions for making necessary journeys more pleasant for all.Issues such as speed enforcement ,raising awareness of the hierarchy of road users help to make active travel to school for instance a more viable option for consideration

# Question 3

The 2021 census shows that 35.1% of households in West Chesterton do not have a car or van. What would you do to broaden the quality and affordability of transport options for non-car owners of all ages to improve access to education, jobs, healthcare and services?

Jamie Leon DALZELL
(Liberal Democrat)

Levels of car ownership is affected by multiple factors.

Many homes in West Chesterton are incredibly well located for quick walks into town, with easy access to a wide range of amenities. You can walk or ride a bike safely to most things you need for day-to-day living, with much of the area having easy access to the car-free routes along the river.

This is, of course, reflected in the property prices in our area, and speaking to members of my community who do not own a car, there are many in West Chesterton who feel lucky to have the choice not to. I think this is reflected in the census data.

A big question for Councillors is how we ensure that all areas of our wards (and city), new and old, can enjoy similar standards and convenience of living – we need to ensure that every area has a broad range of amenities and safe, dedicated (preferably off-road) routes for walking and cycling so that people have an easier choice not to own a car.

Such routes also need to connect into a wider network (especially for accessing facilities with wider catchment areas, such as high schools and hospitals) and ensure that there are adequate and secure parking facilities for cycles and mobility scooters of all shapes and sizes.

However, there are also members of our community who simply cannot afford a car and who are limited in their ability to walk or cycle. This of requires improvements to public transport which are under active consideration (and debate). I think this requires major improvements to our local bus services and I will continue to campaign for franchising (under the power of the Combined Authority) and investment accordingly.

Michael John HARFORD
(Conservative Party)

None for now.

Shayne Mary MITCHELL
(Green Party)

Buses. We need benches/somewhere decent to sit that is not a hard cold plastic perch, and shelter from rain and wind, at bus stops.

Decent up-to-date information at bus stops. Where there is an electronic display, it needs to be clarified whether this is the bus timetable or real-time what is actually happening.

Current £2 limit on bus fares is good - press central government to extend.

Residents' parking schemes. These currently hugely favour car-owning households over non-car-owning households. It costs only £1 a week to park a car whereas a visitor's permit costs £2.50 for each visit - £15 a week. Unfair on those who cannot, or choose not to, have a car. And no incentive not to have a car.

Why not make visitor's permits less expensive? And when they run out - they are valid only for a year or less - make them exchangeable or refundable, as they used to be.

Why not increase the charge for a resident's permit to a more realistic level, as in other towns? Why not have a sliding scale for a second or third car? It seems strange to encourage one house to have three cars, and to store all three on the public highway.

Walking. Too often walking is complicated and difficult - obstructing vegetation, permanent puddles, uneven, dangerous surfaces.

Stop pavement parking.

One very simple measure - where a street is marked as a cul-de-sac, with no exit, add an "Except cycles" sign underneath. Knowing that you can cut through somewhere on foot or on a bike and have a short cut or avoid a nasty main road can make such a difference.

Rachel Lynne WADE
(Labour Party)

As we know,60% of car journeys are for 1 or 2 miles by car, and as we also know reducing 1 car journey per day by active travel can reduce emissions by 10%.Milton Road improvements that are currently underway, I hope, will encourage safe active travel with new cycle lanes, road markings, roundabout priorities, along a major route into the city centre .A sustainable, affordable public transport system, along side , would help to build trust in a reliable cheap alternative for those who are unable to travel actively.Public transport should work in harmony with the residents it serves and provide a dependable service.

# Question 4

The latest work on the Cambridgeshire & Peterborough Local Transport Plan has shown that it would not be possible to meet local and national climate targets with a switch to electric motor vehicles alone. The Combined Authority has summarised a list of the interventions which could be integrated into the region's transport plan to assist with carbon reduction: which of these do you think are most needed in your area to help reduce car mileage and improve sustainable transport?

Jamie Leon DALZELL
(Liberal Democrat)

It is not surprising to me that the Local Transport Plan has found that the large and complex problem of decarbonisation does not have a singular solution.

A switch to electric vehicles will help and there are multiple barriers that need addressing to ensure wider adoption of this lower carbon technology. In West Chesterton this will require solutions to be developed for charging vehicles easily (and reliably) when households do not have off-street parking and we are making some progress and developing our knowledge (both of the good and the bad) with the roll-out of charging infrastructure in De Freville area. We need to ensure that the push for charging infrastructure does not undermine (or deprioritise) active travel infrastructure.

As noted in previous questions, there is scope for significant improvements of infrastructure for walking and cycling in West Chesterton (which would provide benefits to the whole north area of the city), and these would support higher usage of bike/e-scooter hire schemes.

As also noted, public transport improvements are essential – I was pleased to see my first electric buses over past few weeks (they're a lot nicer to ride a recumbent behind) but I am keen to see higher passenger useage, supported by external investment, by measures to effectively prioritise buses (hopefully to be illustrated by tactical placement of bus lanes on redeveloped Milton Road) and reduced, simplified fares. Once great alternatives are in place, we can look at demand management solutions that help keep the overall network moving during rush hour in the city.

Michael John HARFORD
(Conservative Party)

Electric cars were not excluded from the proposals. Why not?

Shayne Mary MITCHELL
(Green Party)

Electric cars are not the magic solution they are advertised as being. They are still cars, with all the problems cars pose of danger to other people, noise, taking up space on the public highway, clutter, decreasing any sense of community and communality.

I would be strongly in favour of a Workplace Parking Levy. It seems strange to encourage people working in Cambridge to drive because they have free parking.

Why not go the full Luxembourg and explore having free public transport throughout the city (and the neighbouring area?), just as Luxembourg - and other places elsewhere in Europe - have done?

Rachel Lynne WADE
(Labour Party)

A joined up comprehensive bus service is important to engage and rebuild Cambridge residents trust. A reliable, dependable ,frequent bus service does much to encourage and empower people to take that step to leave the car at home and use other means. Sustainable transport can build confidence and help to reduce short car journeys, it is an important step along the way in changing perceptions and reducing reliance on cars.

# Question 5

What is your personal experience of walking and cycling in your area? What do you think discourages local people from choosing active travel options for everyday journeys?

Jamie Leon DALZELL
(Liberal Democrat)

When I first moved to Cambridge, as someone who is uncomfortable on a bike, I mainly walked including a daily commute from Chesterton to Station Road (with the unpleasant walk along Elizabeth Way).

Eventually I found a solution to my challenges with balancing a standard bike in the form of a recumbent trike. This proved to be a hugely liberating discovery and has massively improved my mobility and well-being. It has also proved extremely useful when on the campaign trail across the city.

From my experiences, I would note that barriers to active travel were:

Time: When walking daily, there is an upper limit on how far you can go due to time pressures (my walk to work was an hour and a half round trip). As other commitments mount up (such as becoming a Councillor!) faster travel becomes key. For those that cannot cycle; reliable and affordable public transport is essential (with walking to bus stops providing some welcome exercise).

Accessibility: The main barrier for me was finding the right mode of active travel. However, many routes across our city give the bare minimum require for walking and standard bikes to maximise space for private motor vehicles. This can make route simply impassable for wider cycles (like my trike) and discourage the use of a broader range of active travel options.

Safety/Security: Most routes for me across Cambridge are quickest (and most reliably timed) on my trike, but there are routes I avoid due to safety concerns. I know this makes a significant impact on young families in my ward. We need to prioritise safety for our local community on all routes around the city – for example, we need to find improvements for safety along Elizabeth Way.

Michael John HARFORD
(Conservative Party)

My experience is positive. Cars ,cyclists, and pedestrians seem to integrate well.

Shayne Mary MITCHELL
(Green Party)

I've cycled all my life, including in the 1980s and 1990s in London. It is my main method of transport in Cambridge. I go to Bedford often and always use the bus.

Sadly, cycling still feels intimidating and frightening. I avoid main roads, as I have had too many frightening experiences. I avoid being anywhere near buses, as I have seen too often how some bus drivers drive around cyclists (why not give them training to experience what is like on a bike). I use quiet roads, the commons, the towpath etc. and ride very defensively and sedately. Yet I still encounter far too much aggressive, intimidating driving.

Cycling as a way of getting around is glorious - fresh air, the sun on your face, the ability to stop off without thinking about where to dump a large metal object, being able to bump into someone you know and stop and chat, the serendipity, the freedom. It is just such a pity that it can be so daunting.

The disagreeableness of being surrounded by speedy motor traffic - the noise, the sense of danger, the alienation - all discourage active travel.

Far too many friends and people I know have been killed or injured by drivers.

Rachel Lynne WADE
(Labour Party)

My experience is as a pedestrian and a bus user mainly. Both my grown up Sons cycled to their colleges, including to Ely College,so ,as a family we are aware of both the positive and the pot holes of active travel. The green ways are a huge step forward I feel; my experience as a pedestrian means that I am appreciative of clear unobstructed pavements, I am encouraged as a resident of Milton Road of the replanting of trees to provide beauty and shade. I am mindful of the increase ,as a pedestrian, of many forms of electric cycle, scooter,moped , I feel that we need to raise awareness among users of people with different abilities, who may not hear the electric vehicles approach.I would hope that together we can encourage both consideration, awareness of the High way code with regard to respect for each others safety.I am sure that there are discussions to be had around cycle donation for youngsters too, along side cycling proficiency perhaps. Safety for me is essential factor in encouragement, I am aware that speed enforcement is a concern for many residents too

Camcycle is a non-partisan body. All candidates are given an equal opportunity to submit their views. Information published by Camcycle (Cambridge Cycling Campaign), The Bike Depot, 140 Cowley Road, Cambridge, CB4 0DL.